Then and Now: Botetourt County Courthouse

The story below is from our March/April 2020 issue. For the full issue Subscribe today, view our FREE interactive digital edition or download our FREE iOS app!


Modeled after Thomas Jefferson’s designs, this historical structure is scheduled for more modern renovations.



A courthouse often is the center of a community, a place where the public and the law meet.

The Botetourt County Courthouse has been a Fincastle fixture for about 250 years.  

But there have been four different versions of the courthouse at the corner of Main and Roanoke streets. It opened in the late 1700s as a log structure. 

A second courthouse was built about 1820 using architectural designs by Thomas Jefferson. Jefferson mailed the designs from Monticello to Gen. James Breckinridge, according to a historical account by author Robert Douthat Stoner.

The building had a domed top, columns made of walnut logs, stone floors and copper and tin pipes and gutters.

About 27 years later, a third version of the courthouse went up, with a courtroom that extended into the roof and was heated by a fireplace. 

But on December 15, 1970, a fire gutted the structure. Surprisingly, the county’s historical records, locked in a courthouse vault, survived the flames. In 1975, the county built a new, fourth courthouse modeled after Jefferson’s designs. This is the one that stands today.

Now, changes are on the horizon. The building is in need of repairs. Renovations that likely will begin next year will include adding security features, making the space handicapped accessible, mold remediation and more, says Gary Larrowe, Botetourt County administrator.

“It has outlived its usefulness,” he says. 

Also, the county is moving most of its administrative offices out of the courthouse and other Fincastle buildings and into the Greenfield Education and Training Center in Daleville, a permanent relocation.

Offices for the judge, clerk of court and commonwealth attorney will relocate temporarily from the courthouse to the county’s former district court building in Fincastle during renovations, Larrowe says. The refurbished county landmark likely will re-open by mid-2022, he says.  


… for the rest of this story and more from our March/April 2020 issue, Subscribe today, view our FREE interactive digital edition or download our FREE iOS app!

Author

You Might Also Like:

Local Colors Festival May 16 Elmwood Park

Events Calendar May/June 2026

Top May and June Events Around the Roanoke Area
Bruce and Peggy Todaro on the deck of the Green Goat, with the Wasena Bridge behind them.

Wasena Will Come Full Circle Soon

The new bridge, skate park, and blueway will be welcomed by pedestrians, businesses, and customers. 
Artist Casey Murano discussed her watercolor, Come On, Surprise Me, at an artist talk.

Inspired by Nature

The celebration of a heralded book leads to ongoing community projects.
Artist Brian Counihan, Roanoke Arts and Culture Coordinator Douglas Jackson, and other artists and community members create people-centered floats for this year’s Daisy Art Parade in the main floor of Art Project Roanoke, located in the heart of downtown.

Where Everyone’s an Artist

Art Project Roanoke hosts community events on the first floor and artist studios above.
Group photo from one of the two national events Tincher Pitching did this winter in Roanoke, the Pitching Summit.

From Buchanan to the Big Leagues of Softball

When his daughter asked him to teach her how to pitch, Denny Tincher began a journey that would produce a national champion, a historic no-hitter, and a softball training empire rooted in the Roanoke Valley.
Dan Smith / Patrick Harrington

Do You Know… Dr. Mary McDonald?

Dr. Mary McDonald takes her message and her care for large animals worldwide.
This is a 1959 aerial view of Victory Stadium along Reserve Avenue SW.

The Game Changer

In 1961, an NFL exhibition game in Roanoke changed the city and professional football.
The Roanoker May June 2026 Best Of Roanoke Editors Note

Pride in Our People

Our annual Best of issue shows what makes Roanoke strong, resilient, and unmistakably local. 
Vinton’s Historic Gish Mill

Then and Now: Vinton’s Historic Gish Mill

From a 1797 grist mill to future dining and apartments, Vinton’s historic site endures.