The Gist: Murder Hole – Revealed, Explored, Explained

The book is the definitive source for Murder Hole.
The book is the definitive source for Murder Hole.

Say you were out looking at rural property in the Catawba Valley just west of Salem one day, and while your husband was talking to the realtor about a deal, you suddenly came across a giant hole – say 150 feet across, 100 feet wide and more than 100 feet deep.

You could turn and run, grateful you’d found the “problem” with the 34 acres you were considering.

Or, as Marian McConnell describes she did one day in 1993: “I waited impatiently for Dan to walk down the road and join me. We smiled at each other. Not only did we know we were ‘home,’ but that we had been chosen to be the stewards of this miraculous place.”

That miraculous place is the subject of McConnell’s book “Murder Hole,” the Botetourt County cave that is the site of such legends as disappearing cows, a murdered Civil War deserter, the death of a peddler and his horse, and even that the famed Beale Treasure – most often associated with eastern Bedford County, – is actually down in the cave.

McConnell’s love letter to this place takes the form of a 150-page book chock full of facts, stories, more legends, history, stewardship and pretty much anything else related to the hole in her land. Scores of photos – black-and-white and color – add to the mix of what is as definitive a guide to any one place as you’re likely to find.

Even the appendices enrich, primary among them a chronicle of all 80 trips Dan and Marian McConnell had made into the cave as of the publication date.

Haven’t been? Tempted to go again? Please seek permission and presence of the owners: 540-309-4707, or marian.mcconnell@gmail.com

The book is available in hardback ($35) or softback ($24), from Marian McConnell or at the Salem and Botetourt history museums.

Where’s Curt Baker When You Need Him?

Some of us never get over the fence Roanoke City Schools put up around the Patrick Henry High School track for the reported reason of keeping out bicycles, strollers, skateboards and other track-destroying entities. Over the years since, worn spots have inevitably appeared in the tiny entryways through the cattle-catcher fencing, resulting in – for, say, a pre-dawn runner on a morning after rain – totally soaked shoes before the “speed work” begins. Y’all put up a giant fence; can you put up a few little boardwalks so we can get onto the track without wading?

To enjoy more articles like this, download our FREE iOS app or view our FREE web-based digital edition today!

Author

You Might Also Like:

rkr-faces-of

2026 Faces Of Virginia’s Blue Ridge

Welcome to the third edition of FACES of Virginia’s Blue Ridge!
DSC_6819-Edit-2_CMYK

The Face Of Home Décor: WyndRose

WyndRose is an ultimate destination in Virginia’s Blue Ridge for those seeking home décor and design that feels personal, inspiring, and approachable.
DSC_6740-Edit_CMYK

The Face Of Medical Education: Virginia Tech Carilion School of Medicine

As Dean of the Virginia Tech Carilion School of Medicine, I am privileged to help educate the next generation of physicians while strengthening the health and vitality of our region.
DSC_7962_CMYK

The Face Of Professional Lawncare: The Green Team

Joe Kormann and Caroline Adkins operate The Green Team, a family-owned lawn care company based in Roanoke.
Ellen D’Ardenne, Executive Director, and Shelli Schinkus, Director of Sales and Marketing, bring a combined 56 years of experience in the senior living industry.

The Face Of Retirement Communities: The Glebe

Ellen D’Ardenne, Executive Director, and Shelli Schinkus, Director of Sales and Marketing, bring a combined 56 years of experience in the senior living industry.
The Face Of Restoration Services: SERVPRO of Roanoke County

The Face Of Restoration Services: SERVPRO of Roanoke County

When disasters strike, SERVPRO of Roanoke County works to restore what customers already have before replacing it.
Susan Bailey

The Face Of Real Estate: Susan Bailey Realtor, Long & Foster

Susan Bailey has spent more than 20 years in real estate sales and has been the top sales agent for Long & Foster Roanoke for the past five years.
The Face of Community-Based Nonprofit Homecare: Good Samaritan

The Face Of Community-Based Nonprofit Homecare: Good Samaritan

As leaders in home health, hospice and palliative care, we have the privilege of walking alongside individuals and families during some of life’s most vulnerable moments.
Yoshira Buezo & Melida Santos Galvan Housekeeper LLC

The Face Of Professional Cleaning: Galvan Housekeeper, LLC

Owners Yoshira Buezo and Melida Santos have positioned Galvan Housekeeper LLC as a detail-driven, system-based service by building around structure, consistency, and client trust across Virginia’s Blue Ridge.
first bank

The Face Of Community Banking: First Bank

At First Bank, we believe banking is more than just transactions. It’s a people business.