The Gist: Murder Hole – Revealed, Explored, Explained

The book is the definitive source for Murder Hole.
The book is the definitive source for Murder Hole.

Say you were out looking at rural property in the Catawba Valley just west of Salem one day, and while your husband was talking to the realtor about a deal, you suddenly came across a giant hole – say 150 feet across, 100 feet wide and more than 100 feet deep.

You could turn and run, grateful you’d found the “problem” with the 34 acres you were considering.

Or, as Marian McConnell describes she did one day in 1993: “I waited impatiently for Dan to walk down the road and join me. We smiled at each other. Not only did we know we were ‘home,’ but that we had been chosen to be the stewards of this miraculous place.”

That miraculous place is the subject of McConnell’s book “Murder Hole,” the Botetourt County cave that is the site of such legends as disappearing cows, a murdered Civil War deserter, the death of a peddler and his horse, and even that the famed Beale Treasure – most often associated with eastern Bedford County, – is actually down in the cave.

McConnell’s love letter to this place takes the form of a 150-page book chock full of facts, stories, more legends, history, stewardship and pretty much anything else related to the hole in her land. Scores of photos – black-and-white and color – add to the mix of what is as definitive a guide to any one place as you’re likely to find.

Even the appendices enrich, primary among them a chronicle of all 80 trips Dan and Marian McConnell had made into the cave as of the publication date.

Haven’t been? Tempted to go again? Please seek permission and presence of the owners: 540-309-4707, or marian.mcconnell@gmail.com

The book is available in hardback ($35) or softback ($24), from Marian McConnell or at the Salem and Botetourt history museums.

Where’s Curt Baker When You Need Him?

Some of us never get over the fence Roanoke City Schools put up around the Patrick Henry High School track for the reported reason of keeping out bicycles, strollers, skateboards and other track-destroying entities. Over the years since, worn spots have inevitably appeared in the tiny entryways through the cattle-catcher fencing, resulting in – for, say, a pre-dawn runner on a morning after rain – totally soaked shoes before the “speed work” begins. Y’all put up a giant fence; can you put up a few little boardwalks so we can get onto the track without wading?

To enjoy more articles like this, download our FREE iOS app or view our FREE web-based digital edition today!

Author

You Might Also Like:

Local Colors Festival May 16 Elmwood Park

Events Calendar May/June 2026

Top May and June Events Around the Roanoke Area
Bruce and Peggy Todaro on the deck of the Green Goat, with the Wasena Bridge behind them.

Wasena Will Come Full Circle Soon

The new bridge, skate park, and blueway will be welcomed by pedestrians, businesses, and customers. 
Artist Casey Murano discussed her watercolor, Come On, Surprise Me, at an artist talk.

Inspired by Nature

The celebration of a heralded book leads to ongoing community projects.
Artist Brian Counihan, Roanoke Arts and Culture Coordinator Douglas Jackson, and other artists and community members create people-centered floats for this year’s Daisy Art Parade in the main floor of Art Project Roanoke, located in the heart of downtown.

Where Everyone’s an Artist

Art Project Roanoke hosts community events on the first floor and artist studios above.
Group photo from one of the two national events Tincher Pitching did this winter in Roanoke, the Pitching Summit.

From Buchanan to the Big Leagues of Softball

When his daughter asked him to teach her how to pitch, Denny Tincher began a journey that would produce a national champion, a historic no-hitter, and a softball training empire rooted in the Roanoke Valley.
Dan Smith / Patrick Harrington

Do You Know… Dr. Mary McDonald?

Dr. Mary McDonald takes her message and her care for large animals worldwide.
This is a 1959 aerial view of Victory Stadium along Reserve Avenue SW.

The Game Changer

In 1961, an NFL exhibition game in Roanoke changed the city and professional football.
The Roanoker May June 2026 Best Of Roanoke Editors Note

Pride in Our People

Our annual Best of issue shows what makes Roanoke strong, resilient, and unmistakably local. 
Vinton’s Historic Gish Mill

Then and Now: Vinton’s Historic Gish Mill

From a 1797 grist mill to future dining and apartments, Vinton’s historic site endures.