To Reward or Not to Reward…That is the Option

A black-and-white photo of a hand resting on a dog's head as the dog closes its eyes.

Welcome to the eighth post in our Dog Training blog series. This ongoing series features guest posts by local professional dog trainers and highlights some of the big questions they address to their clients. Today’s post was written by Adam Miller of Big Dog Canine Behavioral Dog Training.


Dog owners have four options to choose from when dealing with any behavior demonstrated by their furry family members – they can reward, ignore, re-direct or address the dog’s behavior.  Which option you choose to use will depend on what the specific behavior is and the intensity level of the dog.  Still, no matter which technique is chosen, you must always have a calm and confident manner when dealing with your dog.

REWARD

Good behavior should always be rewarded.  By giving affection, attention, treats or praise to your dog, you will be positively reinforcing whatever behavior your dog is displaying.  Your dog will repeat behaviors that have a positive consequence.  Learn to praise your dog more than you correct them.

IGNORE

Ignoring your dog is a strong communication technique.  It is a simple way of telling your dog that you do not agree with and you will not get involved with their current behavior.  Though it seems simple, to be affective, you must truly ignore your dog…turn away or walk away from your dog while holding a determined energy.  

RE-DIRECTING

Re-directing can work wonders.  Thankfully, dog’s can only do one thing at a time so, if you can get your dog’s focus onto something else, you can get your dog to forget about the original behavior you wanted to stop.  If you can get your dog to chew on a rope instead of your hands, you now have an opportunity to reward and reinforce a wanted behavior.  This technique is very effective with human children as well ☺

ADDRESS

If all other techniques fail, or if your dog or another animal is in harms way, then you need to address your dog’s behavior.  You must use different communication techniques to block or stop the unwanted actions. Be sure to have a calm and confident demeanor whenever you are directly confronting a behavior because your intent is never to physically or mentally harm your dog.

The best way to illustrate these techniques is by observing a puppy harassing an older dog because the puppy wants to play.  The older dog may want to play and can REWARD the behavior by joining in on the fun.  If the older dog does not want to engage in play, it will IGNORE the puppy by turning away, shoulder or butt blocking or by moving away.  If this does not work, the older dog may stop to smell something, get a drink of water or grab a toy, in hope that the new activity will RE-DIRECT the puppy’s focus onto something else.  Finally, if the puppy persists, the older dog will ADDRESS the behavior by growling at, snapping at or physically correcting the puppy.  This correction can sometimes look fierce but there is rarely damage since the older dog’s intent is not to hurt the puppy but only to stop the little guy’s unwanted behavior.

The idea is to understand that you have options when dealing with your dog’s different behaviors.  Try not to get stuck using only one technique…mix them up and try different methods depending on the exact behavior your dog is exhibiting.  I usually like to start with the least invasive options first (IGNORE or RE-DIRECT) to give the dog a chance to quit before I directly block or stop a behavior (ADDRESS).  But, no matter which method you use, it is essential to follow through until the dog realizes the behavior is not wanted and stops.  Always remain calm, confident and consistent when communicating with your dog.  When you correct your dog with an angry and upset attitude, you are punishing your dog…when you correct your with a composed and assertive attitude, you are training your dog.

This post was written by Adam Miller of Big Dog Canine Behavioral Training. For more information or to learn how Adam can help with your dog needs, contact him at bigdogcbt@gmail.com.

Author

You Might Also Like:

Two people in cowboy hats walk down a sunny tree-lined street; the man holds an acoustic guitar.

Gillian Welch & David Rawlings Bring Their Acclaimed Live Performance to Berglund Center on October 22

Berglund Center is proud to welcome acclaimed singer-songwriters Gillian Welch & David Rawlings to Berglund Performing Arts Theatre on Thursday, October 22, 2026.
Aerial view of downtown Roanoke with the Taubman Museum's curved metal roof and the brick train station with columns.

Saturdays July 18 & August 29 Free at the Roanoke History & O. Winston Link Museums

The Roanoke History & O. Winston Link Museums will offer free admission to visitors from Roanoke City, Roanoke County, Salem, Botetourt, Bedford, Craig, Franklin, Floyd, and Montgomery Counties on Saturday July 18 and Saturday August 29, 2026.
The Body Mechanic logo: a muscled human back with arms outstretched, framed by a gear and vines, above "Pain Relief Solutions.

The Body Mechanic Approved as VA Community Care Provider

The Body Mechanic in Salem has been approved as a provider in the VA Community Care Network, giving eligible local veterans access to VA-authorized medically focused massage therapy services closer to home.
A crowd relaxes on lawn chairs and benches under tall trees in front of a covered outdoor stage at dusk.

Grammy-Winning Steep Canyon Rangers and Regional Favorites Phat Laces Headline Weekend at The Dog Bowl

The 5 Points Music Foundation and Black Dog Salvage invite music lovers to a full weekend of live music at The Dog Bowl, featuring Steep Canyon Rangers with Colby T. Helms and Phat Laces with Talking Cake.
ClarityVet Consulting logo: teal paw print inside a gray compass rose, with gray text below.

Clarity Vet Consulting Launches in Roanoke

Clarity Vet Consulting introduces dedicated in-home pet hospice and end-of-life care.
Poster for Behind the Scream with David Arquette, showing a man holding a knife beside a Ghostface mask.

BEHIND THE SCREAM: A Live Conversation with David Arquette

Actor David Arquette takes the Berglund Center stage after a special 30th anniversary screening of "Scream."
A guitarist in a dark embroidered western-style jacket and sunglasses plays a honey-colored Telecaster on a stage.

Joe Bonamassa Announces 2027 U.S. Spring Tour, Includes Berglund Center

Blues-rock titan Joe Bonamassa has announced a new run of Spring 2027 U.S. tour dates, including Roanoke, VA on February 23rd at Berglund Performing Arts Theatre.
Flyer for a mobile pet health clinic on Friday, July 10, 10am-2pm, showing four cats and dogs above a list of service prices and a mobile clinic van.

Angels of Assisi and Bedford Community Pet Coalition to Host Low-Cost Mobile Pet Health Clinic

Angels of Assisi, in partnership with Community Pet Coalition of Bedford, will host a low-cost Mobile Pet Health Clinic on Friday, July 10, in the parking lot of the Bedford County Animal Shelter.
Three people stand smiling in a lab beside a large gray industrial machine with a touchscreen, one wearing a black polo with a logo.

VWCC Designated NC3 Leadership School, Expanding Industry Impact

New applied mechatronics courses will enhance credentialing opportunities.
Roanoke Foodshed Network logo: a circle with a yellow sun, blue mountains, city skyline, and green crop rows.

Roanoke Foodshed Network Awards Mini-Grants in Region

Roanoke Foodshed Network awards $19,375 in healthy community action team mini-grants to strengthen food access and community health in the Roanoke region.