Bread and Butter Pickles, Without the Sugar

Learn how to make sugar-free bread and butter pickles with our recipe below.



One of the great, under-appreciated Southern delicacies of my youth was the bread and butter pickle, which contains neither bread nor butter, but certainly is that basic.

These pickles, made when the garden was at its height (and often served with freshly picked tomatoes) were sweet/sour/salty in just the right proportions to complement any meal. They are a welcome diversion from dill pickles, which remain the staple.

And they are easy to make. I’m diabetic, so I like them without the sugar. Stevia, which I have grown in my garden in the past, is a natural substitute. Buy the granular form. It’s easier to handle.

Here’s what you need:

  • 3 medium-sized pickling cucumbers, peeled and sliced
  • 2 whole scallions, chopped (you can use Vidalia onions, since it’s the season)
  • 3 tablespoons Irish sea salt
  • ¼ cup stevia (sugar substitute)
  • 1 cup apple cider vinegar
  • ¼ teaspoon tumeric
  • ½ teaspoon celery seed
  • ½ teaspoon mustard seeds

Mix the vinegar, salt, stevia, tumeric, celery seed and mustard seeds and add water. Taste to see if you’ve achieved the right balance of Stevia and vinegar. Add whatever you need. Shake well and add the onions and cucumbers. Fill your container (about a quart) to the rim with water. Refrigerate and serve in about three hours.


Dan Smith is an award-winning Roanoke-based writer/author/photographer and a member of the Virginia Communications Hall of Fame (Class of 2010). His blog, fromtheeditr.com, is widely read and he has authored seven books, including the novel CLOG! He is founding editor of a Roanoke-based business magazine and a former Virginia Small Business Journalist of the Year (2005).

Author

You Might Also Like:

AoASummerMega_Graphic

Angels of Assisi to Host First-Ever Summer Mega Adoption Event at Berglund Center

Angels of Assisi is inviting the community to find a new best friend at its first-ever Summer Mega Adoption Event, on Saturday, June 27, from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m. at the Berglund Center Special Events Center.
Mountain Star Herbals logo

Mountain Star Herbals Opens in Downtown Roanoke

Mountain Star Herbals celebrates its grand opening and ribbon cutting ceremony to open downtown Roanoke’s first herb, spice, and tea shop.
George's Flowers logo

George’s Flowers Prepares to Bloom in a New Home on Ogden Road

The multi-award-winning Roanoke florist unveils plans for expanded floral marketplace, educational workshops, and a new customer experience after more than 45 years serving the Roanoke Valley.
SML NO WAKE Map (FINAL June 2026)

Boaters Asked to Go Slow for SML Fireworks Celebrations

SMLA continues its no-wake fireworks boating safety tradition.
Cheryl Sullivan-Willis

Cheryl Sullivan-Willis to Emcee Juneteenth Freedom Jubilee Presentations at Historic Greenfield

Historic Greenfield's Juneteenth Freedom Jubilee 2026 celebration will feature a special afternoon led by Botetourt County resident Cheryl Sullivan-Willis.
WhitneyCummings_ROAN,VA_1080x1080_REV

Whitney Cummings Brings ‘Big Baby’ Tour to Berglund Center in November

Comedian Whitney Cummings will perform her "Big Baby" tour at the Berglund Performing Arts Theatre on November 7.
Kiwanis of Roanoke logo

Kiwanis Club of Roanoke Awards Environmental Scholarship Award of $5,000 to Kai Weiss of Salem

Kai Alexander Weiss of Salem is this year’s winner of the Kiwanis Club of Roanoke’s $5,000 environmental scholarship.
062725_Garden-Gala_tables_img6

LEAP Celebrates Community at Garden Gala Fundraiser

Local Environmental Agriculture Project (LEAP) will host its annual Garden Gala on Friday, June 12th from 6-8pm.